Over the past five years, investors in Dick’s Sporting Goods (NYSE: DKS) have witnessed an extraordinary 433% return on their shares. Shielded from the doomsday retail scenario that once loomed, Dick’s Sporting Goods emerged as a standout success story. However, as we navigate through 2024, my optimism for the stock is somewhat subdued. Let’s delve into the reasons behind this shift in sentiment.
Examining the Achilles Heel
Despite Dick’s Sporting Goods’ impressive performance, a troubling narrative emerges when assessing the future growth prospects of the company. The forecasts for the 2024 fiscal year reveal a modest outlook, with net sales projected to range from $13.0 billion to $13.13 billion. This anticipates a mere 1%–2% growth compared to a 5% uptick in the previous year.
The consensus among analysts hovers around $13.24 earnings per diluted share, placing the stock at a valuation of approximately 15.32 times full-year earnings. While this aligns with the company’s recent resurgence, the valuation may seem a tad stretched when compared to its historical average of 12.62 times earnings.
The Growth Conundrum
Dick’s Sporting Goods has defied conventional retail norms in recent years, deftly navigating competition from behemoths like Amazon (NASDAQ: AMZN). Yet, despite outpacing the S&P 500 over the last half-decade, the stock’s meteoric rise may be due for a breather. Projections for comparable store sales growth of 1%–2% and the limited revenue and earnings estimates paint a picture of restrained progress.
Image source: Getty Images
Recent stock momentum has been primarily fueled by a robust holiday quarter performance, where net sales soared by 7.8% year over year, while net income surged by 26% in the same period.
Although the company reported a net income of $1.046 billion for the extended 53-week fiscal year, the marginal increase from the prior year’s $1.043 billion might leave investors underwhelmed. A significant portion of the gains in diluted earnings per share can be attributed to a reduction in the share count, rather than substantial year-on-year income growth.
Waiting for the Right Moment
These observations do not signal the end of Dick’s Sporting Goods’ growth narrative. Far from it. However, given the muted expectations for the year, the impetus for continued stock appreciation may falter. As a keen patron of their stores and e-commerce platform, I acknowledge the brand’s strengths but question whether a 1% net sales growth can sustain the sizable 87% surge witnessed in the past six months.
For investors considering a prolonged stay, it is crucial to note that the current guidance lacks the exuberance required to fuel a robust bullish trend this year. In fact, the conservative guidance may trigger a stock correction, offering better entry points for long-term-oriented individuals.
Should Investors Commit $1,000 to Dick’s Sporting Goods Today?
Prior to investing in Dick’s Sporting Goods, it is prudent to factor in the following:
The analyst team at Motley Fool Stock Advisor recently highlighted their top 10 stock picks, projecting substantial returns in the near future, with Dick’s Sporting Goods notably absent from the list. This comprehensive service provides investors with a strategic investment blueprint, insightful portfolio advice, regular updates from experts, and two fresh stock recommendations each month. Notably, the Stock Advisor service has consistently outperformed the S&P 500 index since 2002*
*Stock Advisor returns as of April 22, 2024